Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Something is Rotten in the State of BHS

My favorite version of Hamlet was the Franco Zeffirelli version with Mel Gibson. I found that this version definitely created a more ominous feeling of suspense that the other versions lacked. I was immediately drawn in from the very beginning by the eerie background music and scenery. This version also did a much better job with manipulating the lighting of rooms and transitioning from one camera angle to another. During the burial scene, the gold worn born by both Claudius and Gertrude highlights their corruption and possible happiness with the death of Hamlet Sr. Their facials expression also builds up the idea that Claudius and Gertrude could have planned his death from the beginning. All the while, Hamlet can be seen dressed in dark clothes and hidden in the shadows. 
Later on, we see the light from the sun wash over Hamlet the minute Claudius and Gertrude step into the room, highlighting his pun of "I am too much in the sun". Also, Mel Gibson's voice and tone during these first few scenes does a great job of portraying Hamlet's depression. 
Franco Zeffirelli also does a terrific job of playing up the idea of sexual tension between Hamlet and Gertrude. The way he has Gertrude kissing Hamlet after Claudius leaves the room, and the way he has Hamlet watching over Gertrude while performing his first soliloquy, all help show that there is a sexual attraction between the two of them. Also in this version, Hamlet's depression is much more associated with sorrow rather than anger. This helps show that Hamlet's sadness stems from the heartbreak he feels from Gertrude's hasty marriage to Claudius. All these different elements and subtle nuances in the movie help make it stand out among the other versions.

1 comment:

  1. While I did like Zeffirelli's version, it was not my favorite. I agree with you on the point Mel Gibson is very good at acting as Hamlet. However, I think he's a bit too old to be Hamlet. I was disappointed not seeing the first part with the guards and the ghost of Hamlet Sr. That is a crucial part in setting up the eerie and tense mood of the play. It was interesting Zeffirelli decided to show the burial, but you can't beat the first scene. I personally think Ken Branagh's version is the best.

    ReplyDelete